top of page
Search

“Will Korea Collapse Like France?” The Lesson We Must Learn

Nov 9
7 min read

Dr. Kangkook Lee is Professor of College of Economics at Ritsumeikan University in Japan and Affiliated Research Fellow at CUKPE


France is on fire. Protests by students enraged by the poor conditions of schools have spread rapidly across the country, with some demonstrators looting shops and even setting fire to city halls. Voices are erupting in opposition to the government's lack of education spending and inequality.


Some conservative South Korean media outlets reported on the protests in France, warning that if welfare spending and national debt increase due to an aging population, South Korea could find itself in a situation similar to France's. However, is this truly a lesson we should learn from France?


Students and citizens who came out to the streets because they could not attend classes


The driving force behind this protest is French high school students. Teachers do not arrive at the time when classes are supposed to be held. Restrooms are unavailable, and rats are appearing in the classrooms. This is the background behind French high school students taking to the streets to demand the 'right to education.'


The budget for secondary education per student has stagnated for a long time since 2010, and the budget for higher education and research has also decreased. The Macron government has drastically reduced the number of secondary teachers since 2017 and announced plans to cut the education budget and reduce the number of teachers in the 2026 budget as well.


The teacher shortage in French public schools is more severe in poorer regions. Unlike South Korea, public school teachers in France are not required to relocate. Poor suburban areas find it difficult to secure teachers and rely on new hires and contract workers. According to reports, approximately 10% of classes in French public middle and high schools could not be held over the past two years due to reasons such as teacher shortages.


Students' dissatisfaction is also directed at the university admissions system. Through the application platform 'Parcoursup,' introduced in 2018, universities select students based on Baccalaureate scores and high school records. However, the conditions for classes and college guidance provided to students differ between prestigious high schools in Paris and public schools in the suburbs. Even if students are evaluated by the same standards, the opportunity to meet those standards is not necessarily equal. Students argue that the inequality experienced in school can lead to unfairness in university admissions and a disparity in college advancement.


Citizens resisting high living costs and severe inequality have joined the students' protests. With demonstrations against rising rents continuing in Spain as well, protests in France are spreading to other European countries such as Italy and Spain.


Welfare spending was high, but its proportion did not increase.


France's fiscal situation is difficult. According to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), France's fiscal deficit was 5.1% of GDP in 2025 and is projected to rise to 5.4% in 2026. Government debt is also expected to increase from 98.8% of GDP in 2017 to 115.6% in 2026. While France's government spending stands at 57.2% of GDP—the highest among developed nations—government revenue falls short of this level.


Generous pensions and excessive social welfare spending are often cited as the causes of France's fiscal problems. It is true that France's welfare spending and pension benefits are internationally high. According to the OECD, based on average income, the OECD average is 63.2%, Germany is 53.3%, and Korea is 38.9%, whereas France's after-tax income replacement rate for pensions reaches approximately 70%.


Public social spending rose from 31.0% of GDP in 2010 to 30.6% in 2024, showing no significant long-term change except for a temporary increase during the pandemic. Pension-related spending also did not increase significantly in its share of GDP during the same period. The recent fiscal deterioration cannot be explained solely by the fact that the country has high welfare spending.


Of course, population aging poses a burden on future finances. France pays pensions to the retired generation using insurance premiums paid by the working generation and government subsidies. The ratio of the population aged 65 and over to the working-age population rose from 25% in 2000 to 36.8% in 2025. The Macron government pushed through a reform to raise the pension eligibility age to 64 in 2023, but the method of implementation without a parliamentary vote provoked fierce opposition. It is difficult to understand this conflict without considering that the French view pensions as a social contract based on intergenerational solidarity.


Triple burden of reduced tax revenue from massive tax cuts, the pandemic, and the energy crisis


So, what is the cause of France's fiscal problems? To identify the cause of the fiscal deterioration, one must look at revenues along with expenditures. The Macron government narrowed the scope of the wealth tax to real estate and introduced a separate taxation system for financial income. It lowered the corporate tax rate from 33% to 25%, cut corporate production taxes and social insurance contributions, and abolished the housing tax. This was based on the expectation that reducing taxes on the wealthy and corporations would revive investment and growth.


However, while tax cut policies failed to boost growth as much as expected, they weakened the tax base and reduced tax revenue. The French Court of Auditors reported that tax cuts since 2018 resulted in an annual reduction of approximately 62 billion euros in tax revenue, equivalent to 2.2% of GDP, as of 2023. The French Institute of Economic Trends (OFCE) analyzed that changes in fiscal policy, including tax cuts, account for 31% to 48% of the increase in government debt between 2016 and 2023.


Two shocks struck while the revenue base was weakened: the 2020 pandemic and the 2022 war in Ukraine. The French government increased fiscal spending in response to the COVID-19 pandemic and provided large-scale energy subsidies as electricity and gas prices skyrocketed following Russia's invasion of Ukraine.


On top of this, low growth has compounded the situation. France's growth rate did not even reach 1% in the early to mid-2010s, and recently, it has declined from 1.4% in 2024 to 0.9% in 2025. When growth is sluggish, it is difficult to increase tax revenue, and the burden of debt relative to the size of the economy also increases. Ultimately, the fiscal problems facing France must be viewed as the result of a combination of tax cuts, external shocks, and low growth.


The options for the French economy are limited. If securing funding becomes impossible, welfare spending will likely have to be cut to ensure fiscal sustainability. To maintain welfare, reversing tax cuts and reforming the expenditure structure could also be considered. Efforts such as institutional reforms and industrial policies aimed at economic growth are also necessary. The choice depends on France's political decisions and consensus.


The Unfounded Concerns of the Korean Conservative Media and Their Implications for Korea 


South Korea's conservative media expresses concern that the country's future will resemble that of France. For instance, in an article titled "Korea's Future in 10 Years... A Warning from Burning France," the JoongAng Ilbo voices concerns about a future fiscal crisis due to rising pension and welfare spending driven by an aging population. However ,  South Korea's public social welfare spending is projected to reach 15.3% of GDP in 2024, which is only half the level of France. France's prescriptions cannot be applied directly to South Korea, where pensions are insufficient and elderly poverty is severe. Nevertheless, given that welfare demands are clearly bound to increase due to rapid aging, discussions must begin now on how to secure the necessary funds without relying on temporary favorable tax revenues.


In France as well, proposals are emerging to reverse tax cuts and fairly distribute the tax burden. Economist Zucman proposed the so-called "Zucman tax," which would impose a minimum tax burden based on assets on ultra-high-net-worth individuals who can utilize various tax-saving methods. Piketty also proposed the introduction of a "National Solidarity Tax" to tax massive assets and their growth. Both proposals raise the question of "who will bear how much" in the process of reducing the fiscal deficit. Although the conservative media is not discussing it, Korea now also needs to discuss fair and broad tax increases by examining the effective income tax rate for the upper-middle income bracket alongside the taxation of capital gains.


Sharing the benefits of growth is also fiscal policy.


To ensure fiscal sustainability, it is necessary to expand tax revenues while simultaneously strengthening the foundation for economic growth. However, if the benefits of growth are concentrated among a few, the lives of citizens do not improve, and proposals to share the common burden struggle to gain support. Maintaining the community requires concessions from vested interests and social consensus.


In France, where youth unemployment and poverty are significant issues, the intergenerational burden must be considered when discussing pension reform. The path to solidarity would involve the elderly, who empathize with the difficulties of the next generation, making concessions to some extent. In Korea, it is important to reduce elderly poverty while narrowing the gap between regular employees at large corporations and workers in small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and non-regular sectors. The points where concessions and solidarity are needed differ between the two countries.


French students took to the streets because they wanted schools where they could receive proper education. The lesson we must learn also stems from that demand. To safeguard necessary public services, we must secure stable funding, and to gain social consensus on that burden, we must share the benefits of growth. Ultimately, what is needed for both France and Korea is a true spirit of solidarity that fairly shares the financial burden, including tax increases.


(This article was originally published as a column in Social Korea in Korean and translated into English with the help of Google Translate. The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the official stance of the center.)


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


© 2025 The Center for U.S. - Korea Politics and Economy | All Rights Reserved. Contact Us: brianahn@cukpe.org

bottom of page